When victims of shootings can sue for the failure of the Government to report its mental health commitments is a central issue in National Trial Law’s lawsuit on behalf of the victims of the Lewiston, Maine mass shooting. The VA recently released a report detailing a review of the VA’s procedures on involuntary mental health holds that could impact cases like the Lewiston case in the future.
On November 12, 2026, the VA Inspector General released a report reviewing involuntary mental health holds at VA facilities. It stated that the reason for the report is that the Inspector General had received multiple reports about “various concerns” concerning how the VA handles involuntary mental health patients.
The VA has a directive, VHA Directive 1160.06(1), which requires the VA medical center facilities to ensure that facilities follow state and local requirements when it comes to the involuntary commitment of individuals in mental health institutions.
This report found multiple VAs did not have the policies in place to properly handle involuntary mental health holds—with as many as 36% of facilities not even keeping the necessary paperwork and data to ensure compliance. What’s more, only 3 VA facilities had the necessary transfer agreements in place, knowing that they could not properly handle involuntary mental health commitments.
The failure to follow regulations on mandatory mental health holds can have impacts across a wide range of cases. As the VA’s own report notes, involuntary mental health holds can impact an individual’s rights. This includes the right to purchase firearms. This issue has arisen in previous cases National Trial Law has handled, including in the mass shooting context. National Trial Law’s attorneys, Jamal Alsaffar and Tom Jacob, handled the lawsuit against the Federal Government arising out of the Sutherland Springs shooting. Similarly, National Trial Law has brought claims on behalf the families of the survivors of the Lewiston, Maine mass shooting.
The Lewiston shooting case was an Army case, not a VA case; but the lessons are clear for all to see. There, the complaint details facts that the Army had involuntarily committed one of their own soldiers after multiple reports of concerning mental health-related behaviors. But the Army failed to report the soldier and follow proper procedures following the involuntary commitment, resulting in the shooter being able to commit the deadliest shooting in Maine’s history.
In the VA’s case, recent decisions by the VA have made reporting harder and are making it harder to protect communities from gun violence. For example, on February 17, 2026, the VA issued notice that it would stop reporting many commitments to the NCIS background check system.
In summary, the bottom line from the report is troubling: the VA had no reliable way to know who was involuntarily committed, so it could not have reported them reliably.